Agent Career Growth

The Five Questions I Ask Before I Talk About eXp

• By Craig Lerch, Real Estate Broker • 5 Min Read
A dark polished home office desk at dusk with a leather portfolio, a printed worksheet and a brass lamp, the Philadelphia skyline glowing through the window, the hero image for a post on the questions to ask before a brokerage conversation

An experienced agent asked me last week, “So tell me about eXp.” My answer surprised him. I asked him five questions before I said anything about the model. That is not a recruiting move. It is the only honest way to have the conversation, because eXp is right for some agents and wrong for others, and I have sat on both sides of that decision.

Why It Is Coming Up Now

This matters more as the industry consolidates and the pitches get louder. Recruiting Insight and Lone Wolf's Q3 2026 Agent Migration report found about one in eight producing agents switches brokerages every year. And the holding company behind eXp Realty just reported its third quarter: revenue up 6 percent to $1.393 billion, agents and brokers up 5 percent to 87,457, transactions up 8 percent, and sales volume up 10 percent, with a small net loss driven mostly by litigation accruals (AGNT, November 5, 2026). The Q4 report lands February 25. The numbers are public, and I will read them whichever way they land. None of that changes the questions I ask first.

The Five Questions I Ask First

1. What did you gross last year, and what did you actually keep?

The split sheet is where every pitch starts and where most comparisons end. The number that matters is net per side after everything. At the Montgomery County median of about $525,000, one listing side grosses roughly $13,000 at a typical rate, and a five-point split difference is about $660 on that side. If you do not know your net per side, no model conversation is worth having yet.

2. Where does your business come from?

If 80 percent of your closings come from your own sphere, your book moves with you, and the sign matters less than your record. NAR's 2026 Member Profile puts repeat and referral business near 81 percent for agents with 16-plus years. If half your business comes from brokerage leads, the lead model is the conversation, not the split. Those are two completely different questions, and the answer decides which one you are really asking.

3. Can you run your own business for six months without a managing broker down the hall?

Cloud support is real: broker-of-record duties, transaction platforms, training, tools. It is not the same as walking into an office and asking someone a question. The agents who thrive are the ones who already know how to run their business. I tell agents who need that office rhythm that eXp is probably not their fit. That is not a pitch. It is the truth, and it saves everyone a year.

4. What do you want the next ten years to look like?

This is where revenue share gets discussed honestly. eXp's Revenue Share 2.0 pays from the company dollar, the 20 percent eXp retains, not from a recruited agent's commission. Seven tiers, and roughly half of the company dollar flows back to sponsoring agents. The median Tier 1 payout is zero dollars. It is a bonus on a production career, not a retirement plan, and it stops the day you leave. The cap is the real math: 80/20 to a $16,000 annual cap, then 100 percent minus a small per-transaction fee, with no desk fee and no franchise fee. ICON can reimburse the cap in stock for agents who cap early and keep closing. Price all of it against your own side count before you let anyone price it for you.

5. Are you willing to run the whole model, not the pitch?

Every recruiting conversation is a pitch until you run the numbers yourself. I moved my own book at 55 after 17 years of owning a boutique brokerage, and I ran the math for a year before I signed. If you will not do the same, I am not going to sell you on anything. The discipline is the point.

The Honest Part

I have told agents to stay put. I have told agents their current model fits them better than mine does. The model is not for everyone, and the agents who respect that answer are the ones worth talking to. In Montgomery and Bucks, where one side grosses about $13,000 at the median and inventory is up, the real question is what a model costs you while you work the listing, not what the brochure promises.

The Close

I am a broker at eXp Realty, in eXp Luxury and Sports and Entertainment. I say it plainly because I am not neutral in this question. But I did not write this to recruit you. If you are hearing a pitch you cannot price, text me the question at (267) 214-7728 and I will answer it straight. No pitch, and no follow-up if you say no.

Craig Lerch
Craig Lerch

Real Estate Broker · eXp Realty LLC

With Great Gratitude + MORE!!!!!