When the Recruiting Calls Stop, Read the Roster
A producer I have known for nine years wrote me last week. His broker told the office they are raising the bar, and that going forward everyone needs to know where they stand. He does ten to twelve deals a year, has been at the same firm for nine years, and the recruiting calls he used to get have mostly stopped. His question: am I being eased out, or is this just what it looks like from the inside?
Why It Is Coming Up Now
The number that explains the silence: recruiting production at the 100 largest brokerages is down 57 percent year over year through September, and recruiting has fallen from 11.4 percent to 7.2 percent of their annual volume. Attrition fell too, from 8.9 percent to 6.2 percent, and net growth shrank from 2.5 percent to 1 percent. The firms that used to hunt are no longer hunting (Inman, November 5, reporting Courted's data).
The same week, a publicly traded cloud brokerage told investors it is moving its lowest-revenue agents off its platform, and that it has seen an uptick since September in agents leaving the industry altogether (earnings call, November 5). That is a firm pruning its roster in public, which is exactly the move sitting underneath the speech this producer's broker just gave.
One honesty note: this reporting is national, the freshest I could retrieve. Nothing local on Montgomery and Bucks recruiting was accessible this week, so I will not tell you what recruiters here are saying. The local part comes later, from Bright MLS numbers I can check.
The Direct Answer
No, you are not being eased out, and yes, the speech is real. Both are true at once.
Here is the part most recruiting content omits: the speech is not about you. When recruiting cools, firms stop paying to recruit and start managing cost. "Raising the bar" is a sentence about the firm's expense side, spoken to the whole room. Ten to twelve deals a year is a real business, full stop. In this market a side at the median grosses about $12,000 at a typical rate, so ten to twelve sides is roughly $120,000 to $145,000 in gross commission before any split. That is not a number a firm manages out of the building.
What changed is the market for your services as an agent. The calls stopping is not a judgment on your book. Firms cut the recruiting budget as a line item, and the call volume went with it. That is the whole explanation, and it is a dull one.
What Most Producers Get Wrong About It
They read the speech as a performance review. It is a cost decision.
The second-order factor nobody mentions: the producers most likely to be gone next year are the ones who already moved. Producers who switched firms within the past year are 1.7 times as likely to move again (HousingWire, October 29), and agents in offices that lost 20 percent or more of their roster are 1.9 times as likely to follow the departures (Inman, October 20). The signal is not the speech. The signal is the roster. If no experienced producer has walked out of your office this year, the flight risk is not where you are standing.
The second misread is the silence. A quiet recruiting season reads to a producer as "the market does not value me," because the calls were flattering. Do not mistake a line item for a valuation.
The Local Read: Montgomery and Bucks
Bright MLS numbers from this week: Montgomery County closed 689 homes in October at a $485,000 median, nine days to contract. Over the May to October stretch the median was $499,575, six days to contract, at a 101.2 percent sale-to-list ratio, with 1.6 months of supply (county market report pulled November 1). Bucks County shows 529 closings at a $515,000 median as of October 8, with a separate October 6 read putting the county near $528,000 at 27 days to contract (Bucks County Association of REALTORS; local broker compilation).
Run those numbers the way a manager does. A house goes under contract here in about a week and a half. Supply is tight. This is not a county where production is scarce, and it is not a county where a 10-deal producer is a marginal asset. When a firm here talks about its bar, the conversation is about the firm's own economics: franchise fees, buyouts, the cost of the next platform. It is not about the yield of the county's agents.
This is also a market where everyone knows everyone. The same speech is being given in offices across the region right now, and the people who hear the follow-through are the title officers and settlement attorneys in Ambler, Doylestown, Newtown and Huntingdon Valley. If your broker follows the speech with real thresholds and real support, you will see it in the files. If the speech is followed by silence and a worse split, that is a decision too. Either way, the office's own behavior over the next ninety days is your clearest evidence, and it is evidence no recruiter can give you.
How to Actually Evaluate It
Three tests, all run at your own desk.
Number to run: your net per side after everything over the last twelve months, gross commission minus split, fees and company dollar, divided by sides. Then write down what the firm's stated bar would do to that number. A bar you can price is a plan. A bar you cannot price is a mood.
Question to ask the managing broker, verbatim: "What is the bar as a number, and what changes for me above and below it?" A number answer is policy. A feelings answer is a policy being made up in the meeting.
Clause to look up: the termination and notice provisions in your current independent contractor agreement, and any production or performance language in it. I will describe what to look for, but have your own counsel read the document. I do not give legal advice, and neither should your next broker's recruiter.
Then watch the roster for ninety days. Who leaves and who stays will tell you more than any speech.
The Close
I am a broker at eXp Realty, in eXp Luxury and Sports and Entertainment. I say it plainly because I am not neutral in this question.
If the test points at the door: send me your last twelve months and I will run three comp models against your own numbers. No pitch. You keep the spreadsheet. Text or call (267) 214-7728.